Water-membrane partition and the mutant selection window of antimicrobial peptides: insights from liposome studies

The mutant selection window (MSW) is a range of antimicrobial concentrations, where some bacteria are killed, while others survive. Within this interval resistance may develop. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are a promising class of antimicrobials that generally act by perturbing the integrity of bacterial membranes. Their MSW is typically narrower than that of traditional antibiotics, but it still encompasses about one order of magnitude of peptide concentrations. Phenotypic or genetic differences between individual cells may cause this heterogeneous bacterial response to AMPs. Therefore, we minimized the system complexity by investigating pore formation in liposomes with homogeneous size and composition. Surprisingly, the AMPs novicidin, P9-4, and Sub3 formed pores only in a fraction of vesicles, over a wide range of total peptide concentrations. By characterizing the water/membrane partition equilibrium of these three AMPs, we were able to report the vesicle-perturbing activity as a function of the membrane-bound peptide concentration. In this case, the curves became essentially step functions with well-defined (bound) concentration thresholds at which pores were formed in all liposomes. Therefore, the apparent heterogeneous effects of AMPs on vesicles were actually determined by variations in the fraction of membrane-bound peptides under different conditions, due to water-membrane partition. Unexpectedly, the thresholds coincided for all peptides in terms of bound amino acids per lipid (∼0.4), suggesting that the mechanism of pore formation primarily depends on the surface coverage by the AMPs.