High throughput screening (HTS) is routinely used to identify bioactive small molecules. This requires physical compounds, which limits coverage of accessible chemical space. Computational approaches combined with vast on-demand chemical libraries can access far greater chemical space, provided that the predictive accuracy is sufficient to identify useful molecules. Through the largest and most diverse virtual HTS campaign reported to date, comprising 318 individual projects, we demonstrate that our AtomNet® convolutional neural network successfully finds novel hits across every major therapeutic area and protein class. We address historical limitations of computational screening by demonstrating success for target proteins without known binders, high-quality X-ray crystal structures, or manual cherry-picking of compounds. We show that the molecules selected by the AtomNet® model are novel drug-like scaffolds rather than minor modifications to known bioactive compounds. Our empirical results suggest that computational methods can substantially replace HTS as the first step of small-molecule drug discovery.

Wallach, I., Bernard, D., Nguyen, K., Ho, G., Morrison, A., Stecula, A., et al. (2024). AI is a viable alternative to high throughput screening: a 318-target study. SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 14(1) [10.1038/s41598-024-54655-z].

AI is a viable alternative to high throughput screening: a 318-target study

Battistoni, Andrea
Investigation
;
Ammendola, Serena
Investigation
;
2024-04-02

Abstract

High throughput screening (HTS) is routinely used to identify bioactive small molecules. This requires physical compounds, which limits coverage of accessible chemical space. Computational approaches combined with vast on-demand chemical libraries can access far greater chemical space, provided that the predictive accuracy is sufficient to identify useful molecules. Through the largest and most diverse virtual HTS campaign reported to date, comprising 318 individual projects, we demonstrate that our AtomNet® convolutional neural network successfully finds novel hits across every major therapeutic area and protein class. We address historical limitations of computational screening by demonstrating success for target proteins without known binders, high-quality X-ray crystal structures, or manual cherry-picking of compounds. We show that the molecules selected by the AtomNet® model are novel drug-like scaffolds rather than minor modifications to known bioactive compounds. Our empirical results suggest that computational methods can substantially replace HTS as the first step of small-molecule drug discovery.
2-apr-2024
Pubblicato
Rilevanza internazionale
Articolo
Esperti anonimi
Settore BIO/10
Settore BIO/19
English
Con Impact Factor ISI
Wallach, I., Bernard, D., Nguyen, K., Ho, G., Morrison, A., Stecula, A., et al. (2024). AI is a viable alternative to high throughput screening: a 318-target study. SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 14(1) [10.1038/s41598-024-54655-z].
Wallach, I; Bernard, D; Nguyen, K; Ho, G; Morrison, A; Stecula, A; Rosnik, A; O’Sullivan, Am; Davtyan, A; Samudio, B; Thomas, B; Worley, B; Butler, B; Laggner, C; Thayer, D; Moharreri, E; Friedland, G; Truong, H; van den Bedem, H; Ng, Hl; Stafford, K; Sarangapani, K; Giesler, K; Ngo, L; Mysinger, M; Ahmed, M; Anthis, Nj; Henriksen, N; Gniewek, P; Eckert, S; de Oliveira, S; Suterwala, S; Prasadprasad, Svk; Shek, S; Contreras, S; Hare, S; Palazzo, T; O’Brien, Te; Van Grack, T; Williams, T; Chern, T; Kenyon, V; Lee, Ah; Cann, Ab; Bergman, B; Anderson, Bm; Cox, Bd; Warrington, Jm; Sorenson, Jm; Goldenberg, Jm; Young, Ma; Dehaan, N; Pemberton, Rp; Schroedl, S; Abramyan, Tm; Gupta, T; Mysore, V; Presser, Ag; Ferrando, Aa; Andricopulo, Ad; Ghosh, A; Ayachi, Ag; Mushtaq, A; Shaqra, Am; Toh, Akl; Smrcka, Av; Ciccia, A; de Oliveira, As; Sverzhinsky, A; de Sousa, Am; Agoulnik, Ai; Kushnir, A; Freiberg, An; Statsyuk, Av; Gingras, Ar; Degterev, A; Tomilov, A; Vrielink, A; Garaeva, Aa; Bryant-Friedrich, A; Caflisch, A; Patel, Ak; Rangarajan, Av; Matheeussen, A; Battistoni, A; Caporali, A; Chini, A; Ilari, A; Mattevi, A; Foote, At; Trabocchi, A; Stahl, A; Herr, Ab; Berti, A; Freywald, A; Reidenbach, Ag; Lam, A; Cuddihy, Ar; White, A; Taglialatela, A; Ojha, Ak; Cathcart, Am; Motyl, Aal; Borowska, A; D’Antuono, A; Hirsch, Akh; Porcelli, Am; Minakova, A; Montanaro, A; Müller, A; Fiorillo, A; Virtanen, A; O’Donoghue, Aj; Del Rio Flores, A; Garmendia, Ae; Pineda-Lucena, A; Panganiban, At; Samantha, A; Chatterjee, Ak; Haas, Al; Paparella, As; John, Als; Prince, A; Elsheikh, A; Apfel, Am; Colomba, A; O’Dea, A; Diallo, Bn; Ribeiro, Bmrm; Bailey-Elkin, Ba; Edelman, Bl; Liou, B; Perry, B; Chua, Bsk; Kováts, B; Englinger, B; Balakrishnan, B; Gong, B; Agianian, B; Pressly, B; Salas, Bpm; Duggan, Bm; Geisbrecht, Bv; Dymock, Bw; Morten, Bc; Hammock, Bd; Mota, Bef; Dickinson, Bc; Fraser, C; Lempicki, C; Novina, Cd; Torner, C; Ballatore, C; Bon, C; Chapman, Cj; Partch, Cl; Chaton, Ct; Huang, C; Yang, C; Kahler, Cm; Karan, C; Keller, C; Dieck, Cl; Huimei, C; Liu, C; Peltier, C; Mantri, Ck; Kemet, Cm; Müller, Ce; Weber, C; Zeina, Cm; Muli, Cs; Morisseau, C; Alkan, C; Reglero, C; Loy, Ca; Wilson, Cm; Myhr, C; Arrigoni, C; Paulino, C; Santiago, C; Luo, D; Tumes, Dj; Keedy, Da; Lawrence, Da; Chen, D; Manor, D; Trader, Dj; Hildeman, Da; Drewry, Dh; Dowling, Dj; Hosfield, Dj; Smith, Dm; Moreira, D; Siderovski, Dp; Shum, D; Krist, Dt; Riches, Dwh; Ferraris, Dm; Anderson, Dh; Coombe, Dr; Welsbie, Ds; Hu, D; Ortiz, D; Alramadhani, D; Zhang, D; Chaudhuri, D; Slotboom, Dj; Ronning, Dr; Lee, D; Dirksen, D; Shoue, Da; Zochodne, Dw; Krishnamurthy, D; Duncan, D; Glubb, Dm; Gelardi, Elm; Hsiao, Ec; Lynn, Eg; Silva, Eb; Aguilera, E; Lenci, E; Abraham, Et; Lama, E; Mameli, E; Leung, E; Christensen, Em; Mason, Er; Petretto, E; Trakhtenberg, Ef; Rubin, Ej; Strauss, E; Thompson, Ew; Cione, E; Lisabeth, Em; Fan, E; Kroon, Eg; Jo, E; García-Cuesta, Em; Glukhov, E; Gavathiotis, E; Yu, F; Xiang, F; Leng, F; Wang, F; Ingoglia, F; van den Akker, F; Borriello, F; Vizeacoumar, Fj; Luh, F; Buckner, Fs; Vizeacoumar, Fs; Bdira, Fb; Svensson, F; Rodriguez, Gm; Bognár, G; Lembo, G; Zhang, G; Dempsey, G; Eitzen, G; Mayer, G; Greene, Gl; Garcia, Ga; Lukacs, Gl; Prikler, G; Parico, Gcg; Colotti, G; De Keulenaer, G; Cortopassi, G; Roti, G; Girolimetti, G; Fiermonte, G; Gasparre, G; Leuzzi, G; Dahal, G; Michlewski, G; Conn, Gl; Stuchbury, Gd; Bowman, Gr; Popowicz, Gm; Veit, G; de Souza, Ge; Akk, G; Caljon, G; Alvarez, G; Rucinski, G; Lee, G; Cildir, G; Li, H; Breton, He; Jafar-Nejad, H; Zhou, H; Moore, Hp; Tilford, H; Yuan, H; Shim, H; Wulff, H; Hoppe, H; Chaytow, H; Tam, H; Van Remmen, H; Xu, H; Debonsi, Hm; Lieberman, Hb; Jung, H; Fan, H; Feng, H; Zhou, H; Kim, Hj; Greig, Ir; Caliandro, I; Corvo, I; Arozarena, I; Mungrue, In; Verhamme, Im; Qureshi, Ia; Lotsaris, I; Cakir, I; Perry, Jjp; Kwiatkowski, J; Boorman, J; Ferreira, J; Fries, J; Kratz, Jm; Miner, J; Siqueira-Neto, Jl; Granneman, Jg; Ng, J; Shorter, J; Voss, Jh; Gebauer, Jm; Chuah, J; Mousa, Jj; Maynes, Jt; Evans, Jd; Dickhout, J; Mackeigan, Jp; Jossart, Jn; Zhou, J; Lin, J; Xu, J; Wang, J; Zhu, J; Liao, J; Xu, J; Zhao, J; Lin, J; Lee, J; Reis, J; Stetefeld, J; Bruning, Jb; Bruning, Jb; Coles, Jg; Tanner, Jj; Pascal, Jm; So, J; Pederick, Jl; Costoya, Ja; Rayman, Jb; Maciag, Jj; Nasburg, Ja; Gruber, Jj; Finkelstein, Jm; Watkins, J; Rodríguez-Frade, Jm; Arias, Jas; Lasarte, Jj; Oyarzabal, J; Milosavljevic, J; Cools, J; Lescar, J; Bogomolovas, J; Wang, J; Kee, J; Kee, J; Liao, J; Sistla, Jc; Abrahão, Js; Sishtla, K; Francisco, Kr; Hansen, Kb; Molyneaux, Ka; Cunningham, Ka; Martin, Kr; Gadar, K; Ojo, Kk; Wong, Ks; Wentworth, Kl; Lai, K; Lobb, Ka; Hopkins, Km; Parang, K; Machaca, K; Pham, K; Ghilarducci, K; Sugamori, Ks; Mcmanus, Kj; Musta, K; Faller, Kme; Nagamori, K; Mostert, Kj; Korotkov, Kv; Liu, K; Smith, Ks; Sarosiek, K; Rohde, Kh; Kim, Kk; Lee, Kh; Pusztai, L; Lehtiö, L; Haupt, Lm; Cowen, Le; Byrne, Lj; Su, L; Wert-Lamas, L; Puchades-Carrasco, L; Chen, L; Malkas, Lh; Zhuo, L; Hedstrom, L; Hedstrom, L; Walensky, Ld; Antonelli, L; Iommarini, L; Whitesell, L; Randall, Lm; Fathallah, Md; Nagai, Mh; Kilkenny, Ml; Ben-Johny, M; Lussier, Mp; Windisch, Mp; Lolicato, M; Lolli, Ml; Vleminckx, M; Caroleo, Mc; Macias, Mj; Valli, M; Barghash, Mm; Mellado, M; Tye, Ma; Wilson, Ma; Hannink, M; Ashton, Mr; Cerna, Mvcd; Giorgis, M; Safo, Mk; Maurice, Ms; Mcdowell, Ma; Pasquali, M; Mehedi, M; Serafim, Msm; Soellner, Mb; Alteen, Mg; Champion, Mm; Skorodinsky, M; O’Mara, Ml; Bedi, M; Rizzi, M; Levin, M; Mowat, M; Jackson, Mr; Paige, M; Al-Yozbaki, M; Giardini, Ma; Maksimainen, Mm; De Luise, M; Hussain, Ms; Christodoulides, M; Stec, N; Zelinskaya, N; Van Pelt, N; Merrill, Nm; Singh, N; Kootstra, Na; Singh, N; Gandhi, Ns; Chan, N; Trinh, Nm; Schneider, No; Matovic, N; Horstmann, N; Longo, N; Bharambe, N; Rouzbeh, N; Mahmoodi, N; Gumede, Nj; Anastasio, Nc; Khalaf, Nb; Rabal, O; Kandror, O; Escaffre, O; Silvennoinen, O; Bishop, Ot; Iglesias, P; Sobrado, P; Chuong, P; O’Connell, P; Martin-Malpartida, P; Mellor, P; Fish, Pv; Moreira, Pol; Zhou, P; Liu, P; Liu, P; Wu, P; Agogo-Mawuli, P; Jones, Pl; Ngoi, P; Toogood, P; Ip, P; von Hundelshausen, P; Lee, Ph; Rowswell-Turner, Rb; Balaña-Fouce, R; Rocha, Reo; Guido, Rvc; Ferreira, Rs; Agrawal, Rk; Harijan, Rk; Ramachandran, R; Verma, R; Singh, Rk; Tiwari, Rk; Mazitschek, R; Koppisetti, Rk; Dame, Rt; Douville, Rn; Austin, Rc; Taylor, Re; Moore, Rg; Ebright, Rh; Angell, Rm; Yan, R; Kejriwal, R; Batey, Ra; Blelloch, R; Vandenberg, Rj; Hickey, Rj; Kelm, Rj; Lake, Rj; Bradley, Rk; Blumenthal, Rm; Solano, R; Gierse, Rm; Viola, Re; Mccarthy, Rr; Reguera, Rm; Uribe, Rv; do Monte-Neto, Rl; Gorgoglione, R; Cullinane, Rt; Katyal, S; Hossain, S; Phadke, S; Shelburne, Sa; Geden, Se; Johannsen, S; Wazir, S; Legare, S; Landfear, Sm; Radhakrishnan, Sk; Ammendola, S; Dzhumaev, S; Seo, S; Li, S; Zhou, S; Chu, S; Chauhan, S; Maruta, S; Ashkar, Sr; Shyng, S; Conticello, Sg; Buroni, S; Garavaglia, S; White, Sj; Zhu, S; Tsimbalyuk, S; Chadni, Sh; Byun, Sy; Park, S; Xu, Sq; Banerjee, S; Zahler, S; Espinoza, S; Gustincich, S; Sainas, S; Celano, Sl; Capuzzi, Sj; Waggoner, Sn; Poirier, S; Olson, Sh; Marx, So; Van Doren, Sr; Sarilla, S; Brady-Kalnay, Sm; Dallman, S; Azeem, Sm; Teramoto, T; Mehlman, T; Swart, T; Abaffy, T; Akopian, T; Haikarainen, T; Moreda, Tl; Ikegami, T; Teixeira, Tr; Jayasinghe, Td; Gillingwater, Th; Kampourakis, T; Richardson, Ti; Herdendorf, Tj; Kotzé, Tj; O’Meara, Tr; Corson, Tw; Hermle, T; Ogunwa, Th; Lan, T; Su, T; Banjo, T; O’Mara, Ta; Chou, T; Chou, T; Baumann, U; Desai, Ur; Pai, Vp; Thai, Vc; Tandon, V; Banerji, V; Robinson, Vl; Gunasekharan, V; Namasivayam, V; Segers, Vfm; Maranda, V; Dolce, V; Maltarollo, Vg; Scoffone, Vc; Woods, Va; Ronchi, Vp; Van Hung Le, V; Clayton, Wb; Lowther, Wt; Houry, Wa; Li, W; Tang, W; Zhang, W; Van Voorhis, Wc; Donaldson, Wa; Hahn, Wc; Kerr, Wg; Gerwick, Wh; Bradshaw, Wj; Foong, We; Blanchet, X; Wu, X; Lu, X; Qi, X; Xu, X; Yu, X; Qin, X; Wang, X; Yuan, X; Zhang, X; Zhang, Yj; Hu, Y; Aldhamen, Ya; Chen, Y; Li, Y; Sun, Y; Zhu, Y; Gupta, Yk; Pérez-Pertejo, Y; Li, Y; Tang, Y; He, Y; Tse-Dinh, Y; Sidorova, Ya; Yen, Y; Li, Y; Frangos, Zj; Chung, Z; Su, Z; Wang, Z; Zhang, Z; Liu, Z; Inde, Z; Artía, Z; Heifets, A
Articolo su rivista
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
41598_2024_Article_54655.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Versione Editoriale (PDF)
Licenza: Creative commons
Dimensione 1.58 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.58 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2108/359914
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? 0
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact